143: Reviewing in the Rough (12554)

Friday, August 9, 2024

13:00 – 15:00 CT (GMT-5/UTC-5)

Location: Sheraton: Superior A

Session Number: 143
PDW (workshop)
Orientation: International,Research,Diversity
Shareable link: https://cdmcd.co/RxZn5R

Host(s)

NJ

Niranjan Srinivasan Janardhanan

London School of Economics

Facilitator(s)

EM

Elizabeth McClean

Cornell SC Johnson College of Business, United States
EH

Emily Dunham Heaphy

U. of Massachusetts, Amherst, United States
ES

Esther Sackett

Santa Clara U., United States
FP

Frits Pil

U. of Pittsburgh, United States
JD

Jennifer Dannals

Yale School of Management, United States
JK

Jonathan Kush

U. of Massachusetts, Dartmouth, United States
RK

Ravi S. Kudesia

Fox School of Business, Temple U., United States
RS

Ruchi Sinha

UniSA, Australia
SK

Shalini Khazanchi

Rochester Institute of Technology, United States
SG

Steven Gray

U. of Texas at Austin, United States

Host(s)

AR

Alexandra Rheinhardt

U. of Connecticut, United States
JZ

Jingtao Zhu

Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus U., Netherlands

Speaker(s)

BW

Batia Mishan Wiesenfeld

New York U., United States
MK

Maryam Kouchaki

Northwestern Kellogg School of Management, United States
AG

Allison S. Gabriel

Purdue U., West Lafayette, United States

Facilitator(s)

CL

Chak Fu Lam

City U. of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
CR

Christian Resick

Drexel U., United States
CG

Cristiano L O Guarana

Indiana U. - Kelley School of Business, United States

Reviewing is a critical “professional responsibility” and an integral part of participating in the academic community (Trevino, 2008). Yet Tsang and Frey (2007: 129) noted that “there is no formal training for referees who usually pick up their review skills through learning by doing.” This raises a perplexing question for doctoral students and junior faculty: how can one develop critical reviewing skills with so few opportunities to practice the art of reviewing? This PDW provides participants with a rare opportunity to learn and practice the art of reviewing. Prior to the conference, participants will be asked to prepare a practice review of the manuscript by Gabriel, Lanaj, and Jennings (2021) titled, “Is one the loneliest number? A within-person examination of the adaptive and maladaptive consequences of leader loneliness at work”, published in the Journal of Applied Psychology. The actual workshop will consist of two parts: (1) presentations and (2) group discussions. The panel will offer key insights about the review process and quality reviewing from scholars who have served as Associate Editors and Editorial Board Members at leading journals in our field. Allison Gabriel will provide background information about the original submission of their manuscript. Participants will then break into small groups, each facilitated by an experienced faculty member, to discuss and receive feedback on their formal reviews. The PDW will conclude with Dr. Gabriel sharing actual reviews the author team received and how they helped shape the final manuscript.

Participants will be required to conduct a review of a paper to be able to attend Part 2 of the session. Please contact the organizers at j.zhu@rsm.nl to request for a copy of the paper to be reviewed. Please use "MOC RIR" in the subject of your email. Thank you.