Information technology benefits nonprofit organizations. However, the expenditures on technology infrastructure as part of the overhead cost may scare away donations. Do donors care about the information technology adoption and expenses in nonprofit organizations? This study investigates the donors’ reactions to nonprofits’ information technology budget, purposes, and performance. An online survey experiment is conducted on Qualtrics with 1,040 participants. Results show that information technology adoption performance has a positive impact on donations. Surprisingly, donors are more likely to donate to organizations with higher budgets for information technology. However, the detailed information disclosed about the purposes of IT projects negatively influences their willingness to donate. This study suggested a more open and innovative approach for nonprofits to present themselves as tech-equipped organizations to their donors.