Although paradox research recognizes that paradoxes are not ‘a-contextual’, unfolding in space and time, becoming salient through interactions, and being enacted through everyday practices, studies have almost neglected the importance of spatial concepts. With an in-depth digital ethnography on Social Digital Innovation (DSI), we address the question of how individuals use space-making practices to navigate paradoxes. The DSI is characterized as a greenfield humanitarian aid organization initiated by two designers and enacted by the formation of novel spatial constellations entangling a gas station, the digital space Instagram, and connections to Ukraine. Our paper contributes to paradox theory by developing a model of spatial paradox navigation. Firstly, our inductive analysis identifies three interrelated space-making practices we define under the terms: Spacing, spatial meaning-making, and spatial juxtaposing. We analyze how these practices enact a spatial formation navigating the paradoxes “retaining sense of self – adapting new situation change, enabling flexibility – maintaining control/ structure, and maintaining individuality – driving collectivity”. Second, we show how space-making practices dynamically amplify and mitigate paradoxical tensions and impact paradox salience. Accordingly, our conceptual model shows a dynamic entanglement and evolution of paradoxes, spatial formations, and navigation practices. Therefore, we provide a more contextualized, spatial perspective on paradox navigation practices.